Saturday 28 January 2017

In The Stranger, why does society need Meursault to have felt grief at his mothers death?

The
Prosecutor is trying to show that Meursault is an unfeeling, nihilistic person with criminal
tendencies. Because Meursault is so indifferent to the rules of society, the Prosecutor has a
relatively easy time in doing so. Meursault's "society" would be more understanding if
Meursault behaved in ways that conform to their notions of how a compassionate human being
should behave. In other words, if Meursault had cried at his mother's funeral, society
(Meursault's peers) might have been more inclined to believe that killing the Arab was indeed an
accident. But since Meursault was so cold at his mother's funeral and since his behavior is so
odd in court, it is more difficult for them to believe that the murder was an
accident. 

The Prosecutor is well aware of this and well aware of the fact
that Meursault doesn't conform to society's rules and strictures of behavior. Meursault didn't
have a good relationship with his mother and that's why he felt little at her funeral. The
Prosecutor uses this as an opportunity to frame Meursault, not as an honest albeit dispassionate
individual, but as a cold individual clearly capable of murder. At the end of Part 2, Chapter 3,
the Prosecutor says this quite bluntly: 

"In
short," he concluded, speaking with great vehemence, "I accuse the prisoner of
behaving at his mother's funeral in a way that showed he was already a criminal at
heart." 

Seeing that Meursault felt no grief at his
mother's funeral, others find it hard to understand him and certainly they find it hard to
sympathize with him and consider that killing the Arab was a mistake. As the trial progresses,
the indictment becomes less about the actual crime and more an indictment about Meursault's
behavior and existential outlook on life. 

No comments:

Post a Comment

In 1984, is Julia a spy? Please provide specific examples from the book. My teacher says that he knows of 17 pieces of evidence which proves that Julia...

There is some evidence to suggest thatwas a spy throughout 's classic novel . Julia portrays herself as a loyal admirer of Big ...