Friday 27 October 2017

In the play "The Crucible", what does Mrs. Putnam say about Goody Osburn when Tituba accuses her?

This is
actually a very interesting and revealing part of the play, because it shows Goody Putnam's
previously held biases and prejudices.  Earlier in the act, she confesses that she sent Tituba
out to discover "who murdered [Ruth's] sisters."  All of Mrs. Putnam's babies had died
(seven of them), except for Ruth, so, Mrs. Putnam jumped to the illogical and rather ignorant
conclusion that it must have been a witch that had cast a spell upon the babies at their birth,
and that was what had caused their deaths.  She has even formed her own guesses as to who might
have done it; the midwives who helped her to give birth to her children would be
"likely" suspects.

When Hale is first questioning Tituba after
Tituba "confesses," Putnam rather conveniently tosses out Good and Osburn's names,
supplying Tituba with possible candidates for witches.  Tituba is put under severe pressure to
name the names of the women who she "saw" with the Devil, so she grasps conveniently
for the names already mentioned, that of both Sarah Good and Goody Osburn.  After Tituba
mentions them, Mrs. Putnam bursts out with,

"I knew
it!  Goody Osburn were midwife to me three times.  I begged you Thomas, did I not?  I begged him
not to call Osburn because I feared her.  My babies shriveled in her hands!"


As Osburn's name is called out by Tituba, Mrs. Putnam throws in her
emphatic reassurance that this must be true, since her babies died after Osburn helped to birth
them.  This statement reveals that she had already had Osburn in her mind as a suspect
character.  It also shows that the Putnams have great prejudices against some people of the
town, and are ready and willing to supply names that the accusers can then just pick up and use
as scapegoats.   I hope that thest thoughts helped; good luck!

No comments:

Post a Comment

In 1984, is Julia a spy? Please provide specific examples from the book. My teacher says that he knows of 17 pieces of evidence which proves that Julia...

There is some evidence to suggest thatwas a spy throughout 's classic novel . Julia portrays herself as a loyal admirer of Big ...